Why Your First-Round Interview Should Be a Phone Call, Not a Video Call

I was listening to What’s Up Docs on BBC Sounds, and one line stopped me in my tracks: close your eyes, and you’ll spot a liar with 60% accuracy. Keep them open, watching the person speak, and that drops to 35%, worse than chance.

It sent me looking into the research behind it, and it turns out there’s real substance there,  with a direct implication for how HR teams run first-round interviews.

New research suggests that watching a candidate may be making you worse at judging whether they’re telling you the truth.

The finding

A 2025 study from the University of Portsmouth put 120 participants through mock investigative interviews, split into two groups. One group watched video of the interviewee while listening. The other listened to audio only, with no picture at all.

Mind you, the research behind this comes from mock police-style interviews, not job interviews. Participants questioned someone playing a truthful or lying suspect and had to judge which. The findings likely apply to recruitment too, but that’s the context worth knowing upfront.

The audio-only group correctly distinguished truth from lies roughly 62% of the time. The group who could also see the interviewee dropped to around 35%, worse than chance. The researchers’ explanation isn’t that faces “give the game away” in the wrong direction……

It’s cognitive load!

Watching and listening at the same time asks the brain to do more at once: track facial expression, body language, and tone, while also following the content of what’s being said and formulating follow-up questions.

Something gives and what gives is judgement. Audio-only interviewers, freed up from processing a face, asked more questions, asked better ones, and paid closer attention to what was actually being said.

This lines up with a broader, decades-old pattern in deception research: humans are only slightly better than a coin flip at spotting lies in general, and several older studies have found that accuracy is higher for audio-only judgements than for audio-plus-video. The visual channel doesn’t add signal. It adds noise and it costs attention.

What this means for recruitment

We don’t know for certain this applies outside police-style interviews. The study was investigative, not recruitment. But the reason video hurts accuracy is overload from doing two things at once (watching and listening) must still hold? There’s no reason that would only happen to police interviewers. It should hit anyone doing an interview.

So it’s a reasonable bet that a phone first-sift would beat a video first-sift for recruitment too. Not just because it’s quicker and cheaper, but because it might actually get you a more accurate read on the candidate.

That’s awkward for a lot of HR practice, because we’ve been moving the opposite way. Video became the default first-round format, accelerated by the pandemic and never really questioned since, on the assumption that seeing more of someone means judging them better. This research says that assumption may be wrong. More information isn’t the same as better judgement. Sometimes it’s worse.

Practical implications

  • Make phone the default first-round format. Structured calls filter competence and consistency as well,  if not, better than video. It is also faster and thus, cheaper.
  • If you use video, don’t judge credibility from it. Score against what was said, not how it felt.
  • Don’t over-read nerves, eye contact, or fidgeting, they don’t correlate with dishonesty and bias against anxious candidates.
  • Structure beats format. The accuracy gain came from better questioning, not the absence of video. A structured phone interview will always outperform an unstructured one.
  • Keep video for later stages. Candidate experience, panel involvement, roles needing live communication skills. Just don’t rely on it for credibility judgements.

The caveat

This is one study and hot off the press Treat it as a strong signal, not proof. The sample was 120 people in a lab-style investigative-interview setup, not live recruitment. But it matches decades of research showing humans are bad at spotting lies and worse when visual cues are added. That’s enough to pilot on now, without waiting for more studies.

The takeaway

To sense if a candidate’s actually being straight, the evidence says you’ll judge better with your eyes closed than open. A well-structured phone interview isn’t a poor cousin to video. For the first sift, it may be the sharper tool.

So this is why Why Your First-Round Interview Should Be a Phone Call, Not a Video Call!

For more insight and ideas like this sign up to our newsletter here

Source: University of Portsmouth (2025), “Listen closely: research suggests lie detection is more accurate when based solely on listening.”

More Stories

You can’t stop the waves, but you can learn to surf.

You can’t stop the waves, but you can learn to surf.

There is a saying that I often hear in Cornwall……you can’t stop the waves, but you can learn to surf. I come back to that line again and again in my work, because it sums up where so many organisations are right now.

Strategy Is More Than a Plan!

Strategy Is More Than a Plan!

An Open Leadership Masterclass Programme, Starting 21st October in Cornwall Most organisations don't have a strategy...